REVIEW: “IN MY HEART” Anthology by Joe Cosentino


TITLE: In My Hearth Anthology
AUTHOR: Joe Cosentino
PUBLISHER: Dreampsinner Press
GENRE:  Contemporary Romance
PRICE: $ 14.99 on Dreamspinner store
LENGTH: 200 pages
RELEASE DATE: 21st March 2016


BLURB: An Infatuation

With his ten-year high school reunion approaching, Harold wonders whether Mario will be as muscular, sexy, and tantalizing as he remembers. As a teenager, it was love at first sight for Harold while tutoring football star Mario, until homophobia and bullying drove Mario deep into the closet. Now they’re both married men. Mario, a model, is miserable with his producer wife, while Harold, a teacher, is perfectly content with his businessman husband, Stuart. When the two meet again, will the old flame reignite, setting Harold’s comfortable life ablaze? How can Harold be happy with Stuart when he is still infatuated with his Adonis, his first love, Mario? Harold faces this seemingly impossible situation with inimitable wit, tenderness, and humor as he attempts to reconcile the past and the future.

A Shooting Star

On the eve of the best night of his life, winning an Academy Award, Jonathan Bello thinks back to his one great love, David Star.

Flipping back the pages of time, Jonathan recalls his handsome, muscular, and charismatic college roommate. Since Jonathan was a freshman and David a senior in the Theatre Department, David took Jonathan under his wing and molded him, not only as an actor but as a lover. With every wonderful new adventure, David left his joyful mark on anyone with whom they came in contact, but Jonathan soon uncovered David’s dark past, leading to a shocking event. Undaunted, Jonathan celebrates the captivating man who will always hold a special place in his heart.

A Bittersweet Dreams title: It’s an unfortunate truth: love doesn’t always conquer all. Regardless of its strength, sometimes fate intervenes, tragedy strikes, or forces conspire against it. These stories of romance do not offer a traditional happy ending, but the strong and enduring love will still touch your heart and maybe move you to tears.


lorraineAn Infatuation: You may search through numerous Oyster Beds and never find a Pearl, but late into the early hours of this morning, I found a Pearl – the perfect Pearl, in this wonderful storyline told in flashbacks.
The Author executed his storyline with a marvellous precision that would be the envy of many Authors. He draws the readers into the lives of his characters, they become real and in turn, their emotions becomes yours.   Because the storyline is told in flashbacks, I knew what was coming? didn’t I? yes, I did! so why the tissues then? – because I got so involved, I was left an emotional wreck!
The storyline sounds simple enough, but don’t let it fool you – it’s not! It’s devilishly complicated, the Author forewent the pistols and went straight to the big guns! he didn’t take prisoners, it was all or nothing.
For me, it was Team Harold all the way – he owned it! Stuart and Mario played the “walk-on’s” for me – soon forgotten. Mr. Ringwood will be someone whom you can remember his face, but stumble over his name – but he did leave mark. Unlike Harold – Harold will always be remembered! Looks can be deceiving – Harold deceived. He was strong, so, so strong!
That’s all I’m going to say, no spoilers, no hints. Whoever said that “your school years are the best years of your life” needs to be found and shot with the big guns that I spoke about earlier.
Read this book. If you can only afford to buy one more book this year? buy this one. I cannot recommend it enough, definitely one of my favourite reads of 2015! Five, big fat, tear glistened stars from me (more if I could).

A Shooting Star: Five beautiful shooting stars, this book lit the darkest night.

This book lit the nighttime sky with shooting stars galore, so how do you rate/review a book that is just so heart-wrenchingly beautiful, that no words I possess in my vocabulary, would do it justice? That is my first dilemma! My second? I’ve already given 5* to the two previous books that I have read by this amazing, gifted Author and this bitter sweet chef-d’oeuvre, merits a higher, superior rating but here at threebooksovertherainbow, we plateau at a 5 star maximum. So I hope you can see my difficulty?

So while I think through my predicament, I’m going to share my thoughts on the storyline (without spoilers and giving anything away – the blurb covers it remarkably well) while waiting for inspiration to materialise.

This short but powerful story is about hope, love and aspirations – a yearning that may or may not, transpire. I got the impression that this Author is very vigilant in his observations of people and then he personifies them in his writing, with a certain embellishment, that is so entertaining to read. The whole book is littered with humour, that is natural but so engaging.

David takes young Jonathan under his wing right from the very beginning and steers him in the right direction on learning how to read people and therefore enhancing his future acting abilities. They become firm friends and this develops into so much more for Jonathan, but David has secrets! Where does he go when he leaves Jonathan at night? What influence has David’s father got over his life? Is David really the brightest star in the sky, shining brightly to show people the right way to go? or is Jonathan blinkered by the bright light and being led like a month to the flame – only to get burnt? And then there’s Barry. For me, he stole the show! – I truly doted on him, relishing in his dependability – for me, he shone brighter than the leading stars.

Again Joe Cosentino drew me into his wonderful world of part fact/part fiction/loosely based on his own experiences world – a world as a reader I love to enter, time and time again. Maybe not the ending that I hoped for, but then again on reflection, could it have ended any other way? Most probably not.

My predicament is still here, I haven’t solved it and most probably never will. Read and delight in this bitter sweet pleasure that this Author offers and maybe leave your own review, to do this book justice, as I’ve failed in my effort to do so.

infinito 5e
****I would like to thank the Author for the opportunity and privilege of reading this ARC. My review was an honest opinion of the book****


Dear Readers,

     I am incredibly touched by your many messages in praise of my two e-book novellas from Dreamspinner Press, AN INFATUATION and A SHOOTING STAR, including how reading them changed your lives. This is especially important to me since AN INFATUATION is loosely based on my years in high school and my ten-year high school reunion, and A SHOOTING STAR is loosely based on my time as a theatre major in college. Your support and enthusiasm helped AN INFATUATION win Favorite Book Cover and 2nd Place Favorite Romance Novel in Divine Magazine’s Readers’ Poll of 2015, and me win 2nd Place Favorite Author. Now your embracing of these two novellas has caused Dreamspinner Press to publish them together in a paperback under the title IN MY HEART, releasing March 21. I hope you will embrace the paperback anthology in the same way as you did the e-books. Thank you from–in my heart. Hugs.

Joe Cosentino


Purchase Links:


Praise for AN INFATUATION (Divine Magazine’s Readers’ Choice Award for 2015: 2nd Place Best MM Romance Novel, 1st Place Best Cover Design):

“The author executed his storyline with a marvelous precision that would be the envy of many authors. He draws the readers into the lives of his characters, they become real and in turn, their emotions becomes yours.” “If you can only afford to buy one more book this year, buy this one.” Three Books Over the Rainbow Reviews

“I really loved this book and having an ending that made me laugh and cry at the same time is testament to the brilliant writing.” BooksLaidBareBoys

“I think you will be left breathless with the reality and emotion behind An Infatuation.”  Diverse Reader

“Don’t miss this one friends, it is a heartfelt story magical in the telling! Thanks Joe for putting your heart on the page for us to savor!” Bike Book Reviews

“Author Joe Cosentino brought just the right amount of humor, angst and honesty to make this short but sweet coming of age story a success.” MM Good Book Reviews

“Joe Cosentino proves there’s more than one way to a happy ending in An Infatuation, a story of first love and heartbreak delivered in a fresh and funny voice.” The Novel Approach

“It’s unusual for me to get sucked into a book in the first chapter but it grabbed me early and I read the whole thing in one day”. Nautical Star Books

“I recommend this book to anyone reminiscing about that one that got away.” LoveBytes Reviews

“There were times I laughed and then there were times I cried…unforgettable.” Multitaskingmomma Reviews

“Like an onion, Joe Cosentino’s stories have layers. I would really recommend them. This is a Bittersweet novel, but it has laughs-a-plenty despite the sad and ugly lurking beneath the veneer. A truly fabulous read.” Boy Meets Boy Reviews

The story kept me turning the pages and I thoroughly enjoyed it from start to finish.” “I love that Harold found what he was looking for in life and in a partner and love that he has his HEA. Great read.” Up All Night, Sleep All Day

“just the right dose of humor, honesty, and of course, sweet romance” Readers’ Favorite


“unbelievably beautiful” “a masterpiece” Lovebytes Reviews

“heart-wrenchingly beautiful, that no words I possess in my vocabulary would do it justice” “Again Joe Cosentino drew me into his wonderful world of part fact/part fiction/loosely based on his own experiences world – a world as a reader I love to enter, time and time again.” Three Books over the Rainbow

“A Shooting Star could easily function as a master class in how to write short fiction (or any fiction). Joe Cosentino has provided a work that will leave you thinking and wanting to savor and re-read it again and again.” GGR Reviews

“This is a bittersweet love story, so don’t be surprised if you find tears running down your face when a shining and burning star is extinguished too soon. But, as Joe Cosentino proves time and time again, with his wonderful writing and storytelling ability, love will prevail, and you will smile from ear to ear.” Kathy Mac Reviews

“For those readers looking for something a little bit different – dare I say unique? For those readers who like to laugh. For those readers who appreciate the nuances of people and the way each character is different. For those readers who want to read a damn good story – check out this author. I’m glad I did.” Boy Meets Boy Reviews

“Cosentino has another winning heartbreaker with A Shooting Star.” Prism Book Alliance.

“Yes, it is a bittersweet story but it is one that still has hope and love.” Hearts on Fire Reviews

“This story just blew me away.” “If you like something different from time to time, a bittersweet story, actors, college men, and a very sweet romance I highly recommend this.” Cathy Brockman Romance/MM Good Book Reviews

“From the beginning I was enthralled and couldn’t wait to finish the book.” Inked Rainbow Reads

“really grabs you and tugs at your emotions” “unique and enjoyable.” Nautical Star Books

“a sophisticated, enthralling and suspenseful tale with a gothic vibe and a multi-layered execution that will have you sitting up and taking notice. This is polished prose at its best. Intelligent writing, a thought-provoking plot and characters befitting the theater genre make A Shooting Star one of my favorite reads this year.” Love’s Last Refuge Reviews

“a beautifully written story, full of life, love, heartbreak, tragedy, and maybe most importantly, triumph.” Readers’ Favorite


Web site:






Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s